Pure aluminum radiant barrier foil has a 97% reflectivity. This means it’s only letting about 3% of that heat pass through.
No Air Gap = No Radiant Heat = It Won’t Work!
In order for radiant heat to exist, you MUST have this air gap. If you don’t have this air gap, you CANNOT scientifically possibly have radiant heat because if you sandwich two products together and eliminate that air gap, you have conduction, or conductive heat.
If you don’t have radiant heat, you don’t need to install a radiant barrier – it just doesn’t work. Hopefully this clarifies exactly why an air gap is REQUIRED any time you plan to install any radiant barrier.